Picture
Last week, the TSA (Transportation Security Administration) announced that pocket knives and other previously banned items will be allowed in airline cabins starting this April. Despite these new rules with possibly threaten the safety of passengers, the screening conducted by airport security will not get any easier; therefore, passengers will still have to take of their shoes and go through all of the screening methods they previously had to. According to these new rules, knives with blades that are 2.36 inches (6 centimeters) or shorter and less than a half inch wide will be allowed on planes as long as the blade is not fixed or locks in place. However, razor blades and box cutters are still prohibited. These new rules also allow passengers to carry up to two golf clubs, toy bats, and sports sticks. Many are opposed to these new rules, including Senator Charles Schumer who said "These items are dangerous, and have not become less so in the years since they were banned from planes."  However, despite strong scrutiny from others, TSA chief John Pistole said that "the changes will bring the United States into alignment with international rules and are in keeping with a 'risk-based security' approach that will allow screeners to focus on items such as liquid explosives and improvised bombs that pose a greater threat to aircraft." Representative Michael McCaul, R-Texas, who is the chairman of the House Homeland Security Committee, said that he supports these new rules, and that the "TSA must continue to improve its risk-based screening and one of its highest priorities must be securing commercial aviation from the type of threats and weapons that could bring down an aircraft. Any modifications to our security system must enhance our ability to detect such threats. As I have stated, my priority is to make TSA more passenger-friendly and threat-focused." Supporters of these new rules argue that the search for these types of knives interferes with the search for objects that can truly threaten aircrafts.
    In my opinion, I do not like these new rules. I don't understand how any good could come out of allowing knives on planes. Ever since 9/11, and the subsequent increases in airport security, we haven't had any major tragedies. So why would you fix something that


Matthew Nickles
3/13/2013 11:43:51 am

I can see where supports of this new rule is coming from. I understand that explosives pose a larger threat and this rule would allow them to focus on finding those more. After all, if our biggest threat we are trying to combat when it comes to air travel is terrorism, then they wouldn't be using just a knife. I also feel that maybe the type of knife that they are allowing and the rule of the 2.36 inches allow for if something did happen, the puncture would wouldn't go deep enough to inflict serious damage depending on where you stab them. However, overall, I agree with Nick. I don't see what good could come in allowing knives on planes. As for the argument saying that it would speed up security checkpoints, I feel like this would do the complete opposite as they would have to check and measure and approve every single person who has a knife. I understand that the TSA wants to keep the pace with international air travel regulations, however, this is not the right way to start that.

Reply
Raj Bhagowalia
3/14/2013 03:42:48 am

I can somewhat understand where this idea is coming from, but I think it is really stupid overall. Allowing weapons of any kind or size is only going to result in violence, so why do it? We have had a good streak of peace in airports since 9/11, so I don't believe changing any rules is necessary.

Reply
Andy
3/18/2013 01:28:55 am

Knives aren't always weapons Raj. America is a lot bigger than our sphere of northern Virginia. Many people out west have knives on them like we have our wallets, for them, it's simply a do all tool. Just because a very small blade is allowed on a plane doesn't mean that there are going to be melee free for all's going on. Trying to kill someone with a 2.36 inch blade is like trying to kill someone with a teddy bear, very difficult unless you really know what you're doing.

Reply
Catherine Soltesz
3/17/2013 10:06:49 am

These new rules make me feel less safe while traveling. The world is not getting to be a safer place, and someone is going to take advantage of these new relaxed rules. A knife is still a knife, no matter the size. The TSA need more people working to make security faster, allowing small knifes is not the answer.

Reply
Andy
3/18/2013 01:22:35 am

This is an interesting decision. I can see why they would like to prioritize their efforts on catching explosives, since they are a far more direct and common threat to the safety of airline passengers than one person with a small knife. Being a decision on safety, I'm sure that they thought this through for a while, and think that it is fairly reasonable.

Reply



Leave a Reply.